PhotoDude.com

Wed. Sep 28, 2005

Operation Eden: The Good Son

Over the past year or so, I’ve become quite cynical about the world of web logs and what it has become. Of course, there’s as much diversity as their is in humanity, but the trend I see is a lot like Reality TV; “I’ll do considerably degrading and disgusting things, because I want to be famous!” And since I’ve decried the ugly, I feel an obligation to also point you to its plain and sparkling opposite. Because the other day I stumbled across a blog that simply stunned me, and actually made me think “this is why blogs were invented.”

It has nothing to do with the design, as it’s a basic Blogger/Blogspot site. It has nothing to do with a partisan political position, because there isn’t one (other than overall disgust). It’s about the content, all clearly directly from the heart.

You should probably just stop reading this and go there: Operation Eden, “A personal chronicle of what hurricane Katrina has done to my poor proud people.

Oh, I know, you’re over it, you’ve seen tons of coverage of Katrina. Not like this. Clayton Cubitt is a man about whom I know very little. In fact, I made a point of not delving into his “backstory,” as it is irrelevant to what you’ll see at Operation Eden, but I gather he’s a professional photographer of some type. All I know for certain is that he’s a man who loves his family dearly, a man who may have left his poor town but never left his roots. His mother and younger brother lived on the coast right in the path of the worst of Katrina, in a home that he had bought for them using all the money he had at the time. It’s wiped out now. After the storm, he loaded up with supplies and went to find them.

He eventually made it to his mother’s home in Pearlington, Mississippi, wheremaybe 600 of the town’s 1,700 souls — are still living in tents and under tarps. Folks here say Pearlington is an old and generally overlooked town, a place where blacks live in one section and whites in another. It’s a place without a mayor or a town government — in other words, without an advocate.

In other words, a month after Katrina, they still haven’t gotten squat. Clayton finally convinced his Mom to let him take them all to a motel in Jackson, Mississippi, for a few days, so they could have normal things like a hot shower, electricity, air conditioning, and some news. His mother still hadn’t even seen a picture of what happened in New Orleans. It made her cry, despite all she’d been through.

But I should probably just stop there. And you should probably just go to Operation Eden, and then scroll all the way to the bottom. Start at the beginning. Put aside an hour, and go through it. It will be the best hour you’ve spent on the web this year.

It’s hard for me to even point you to excerpts, but look at this picture of his mother: “This is what it looks like when poor people have lost it all, and are told to get in line.

Read how he felt upon “Homecoming.

I’m fucking disgusting. An interloper in a nice rental car with air conditioning. An alien tourist with an expensive camera. A carpetbagger. These people, my people, have been brought so low. They were on the bottom before Katrina, but she’s stomped their faces into the mud, deep and black. They’re below the bottom now, if it could be believed, and it’s killing me.

And my family can’t even feel singled out in this massive misfortune. If one of them were to be murdered, or mugged, we could cry and blame and feel the warmth of a spotlight of wrongs. Not so here. One of thousands. Hundreds of thousands. A huge swarm of loss. A plague.

I can’t think. I need to state facts alone, because context breaks my heart and I feel ashamed to have a broken heart around such poverty and devastation and loss, even if it’s also mine.

The text is heart wrenching. The photos are hypnotizing. And the plight is ongoing. Upon encountering an old friend who was “like long-lost family, baked skin, wearing only faded cut-off jean shorts, bare feet”, the man told themGet the hell out, keep going, don’t look back, there’s no help coming for us.

Look at The Contents Of My Mom’s Life: “It all fits on a small coffee table.

This may sound like a strange thing to say about such an obvious outpouring of pain … but this is Art. With a capital A. An unfiltered expression that moves you to a place you’ve never been before. It doesn’t just tell a story, it grinds it into your consciousness.

So many bloggers are wannabe “journalists,” wondering what sort of laptop and camera they should have to enable them to “report news.” Because surely all it takes is the right equipment. Well, Clayton touches on that, but to call this journalism would be degrading. It is far from dispassionate or unbiased, and it isn’t the “outside looking in.” It is as inside as it gets.

It’s Art. I feel like that somehow minimizes the pain of these people, or implies that’s why Clayton put the site up (when that’s clearly not true at all)... but that’s all I know to say. It made me cry. It made me smile. It made me come back and look at it again. It’s Art. It’s everything that the combination of photos and words on the web should be ... but very very rarely is.

And remember that curmudgeon who told you “you’re on your own”? Clayton is a kindred spirit, with hard experience at hand:

You are on your own. My advice to you: have lots of private insurance for everything. Have fresh water on hand. Batteries and gas lamps. A generator. MREs and Powerbars. Plenty of cash. A gun, preferably a 12-gauge shotgun. Know how to use it, it will be worth it’s weight in gold. It doesn’t matter how the destruction will come. Hurricane. War. Terrorism. But when it comes, know that you are on your own.

You are always on your own. The government takes care of itself, not it’s citizens.

Clayton’s words and photos make the case exceedingly well. His family is on its own. If there’s anything you can do to help them, please do.

Later: More from Clayton on how you can help the people of Pearlington, Ms., including an address to ship a box via UPS or FedEx to the town school. They need the simplest of things: “Packaged socks, and underwear, all sizes (and I was told by a big girl not to forget the big girls in this size request), Daily toiletries, like deodorant, shaving cream and razors, and soap (including laundry soap), Bug spray and sunblock, Daily staples like coffee, sugar, salt, pepper, Towels, all sizes…” And lots of other things we take for granted.

Peanut Gallery

1  Todd H. wrote:

I’m probably going to come off as the world’s greatest cynic, or an incredible HFC (the first word is ‘huge’, the last is ‘curmudgeon’, you figure out the middle one), but here I go anyhow, because I’m getting somewhat fed up:

You are on your own. My advice to you: have lots of private insurance for everything. Have fresh water on hand. Batteries and gas lamps. A generator. MREs and Powerbars. Plenty of cash. A gun, preferably a 12-gauge shotgun. Know how to use it, it will be worth it’s weight in gold. It doesn’t matter how the destruction will come. Hurricane. War. Terrorism. But when it comes, know that you are on your own.

True. Completely and 100% True. Truer words were never spoken. But… why in the world is it that people seem to think this comes as a great surprise? Why do people feel slighted when the government doesn’t swoop down upon their property after a disaster, and fix their life first, before the other 750,000 other folks in just as bad a mess? It’s becoming painfully clear to me that we have a significant segment of the population that not just can’t help themselves, they won’t.

I have great sympathy for the people hurt in any disaster, be it natural, terrorist, or even economic. I start losing sympathy when the victims start acting like they’re being put out because the problems aren’t fixed in 20 minutes. The people working to help aren’t getting any joy out of this taking a long time, no matter what the media would have you believe. I’d wager as many relief workers will need therapy as will victims.

The blog is good, if you can get by the bitching because there’s a line at the FEMA relief stations.

Just go stock up, and be aware that no matter what the tough situation is, realize you’re going to have to help yourself at least for a bit, and you are going to have to be patient for a lot longer than a bit. This shouldn’t have come as such a suprise, but it will again soon- next hurricane, earthquake, or terrorist act. I betcha.

2  Paul wrote:

I think it has something to do with the fact that Americans just spent 2.4 trillion dollars on something that doesn’t work.

Comment by Paul · 09/29/05 03:15 PM
3  Reid wrote:

Todd: “an incredible HFC

Sorry, that title is taken at this site. More below.

Why do people feel slighted when the government doesn’t swoop down upon their property after a disaster, and fix their life first, before the other 750,000 other folks in just as bad a mess? It’s becoming painfully clear to me that we have a significant segment of the population that not just can’t help themselves, they won’t.

It’s true, somebody has to be at the very end of that line of 750,000. If you could judge by this one site, it appears to currently be the citizens of Pearlington, Mississippi.

But I’m going to have to assume you’re talking about some generic “people,” because at the cited site, it appears a son travelled about a thousand miles to help his family, found them “helping themselves” as best they could with no home, no car, no power, no cash, no running water, etc., and that he evacuated them to a brief respite in civilization on his own.

It appears his mother works for the state of Mississippi … “helping distribute food stamps to the poor, and helping to make sure that dads pay child support. She makes $6.91 an hour before taxes, and she feels it’s the best job she’s ever had.”

Helping others.

The rant about FEMA to which you refer wasn’t about a line of people who expect FEMA to “swoop down upon their property after a disaster, and fix their life first.” They are in line to file a new claim , one that will, at best, garner them a $2,000 check, some day, if they can find a bank to put it in. And maybe, some day, a trailer.

If you want to check on your previously filed claim, you get the infamous FEMA 800 number (what, you have no phone and no power?), that everyone I’ve heard in Mississippi and Louisiana (state officials included) has said is constantly busy, and often results in a mistransferred call that the operators admit has happened because their system is overwhelmed.

I start losing sympathy when the victims start acting like they’re being put out because the problems aren’t fixed in 20 minutes

That rant was written on September 16th, just shy of three weeks after the storm hit. And at the end of the day in that FEMA line, they were still turning away people who merely wanted to file a new claim.

Not have someone immediately “fix their life.”

The lesson here is not just that “you’re on your own,” and with patience, can expect help. The lesson is simply … you are on your own, and any help you get from FEMA, the Red Cross (who Clayton also says is nowhere to be found), or any official should be considered an unexpected surprise. No matter what they claim they are going to do for you.

Are there whiners out there? Well, when haven’t there been? But in this case, it sounds to me like a good son travelled a thousand miles to help his family out, and set up a web site to raise funds, not demand a the government “fix their life.” You want them to help themselves? I’m not sure what more you would have them do.

Paul: “I think it has something to do with the fact that Americans just spent 2.4 trillion dollars on something that doesn’t work

You mean, a new federal department in charge of our disaster response system in the case of an “Incident of National Significance”? Well, it’s best we have that illusion shattered now, rather than after the next attack.

Maybe there will be less whining then.

Comment by Reid · 09/29/05 03:33 PM
4  Reecie wrote:

Sigh. That website is simply beautiful. Heartwrenching, of course, but still so beautiful.
Thanks, Reid.

Comments are closed for this article

SEARCH The Daily Whim

OR BROWSE BY CATEGORY

SEARCH ENTIRE SITE

ARCHIVES:
 Articles, Photos, Links, Quotes, Downloads
ELSEWHERE:
 flickr, del.icio.us, twitter
Feeds
FEEDS:
 One Big Feed
TEXT ONLY:
 RSS/Atom
PHOTOS ONLY:
 RSS/Atom

Recent Comments

ReidStott.com

Web Design &
Photography
by Reid Stott
Web Design & Photography by Reid Stott A decade of web design experience. Two decades of photography experience. All available to you, and your project. View my portfolio online, then let's talk about your needs.

ReidStott.com

Contact me to find out more