Sat. Oct 03, 2009
We Are Covered In Bipartisan Bull
I was on the road most of last week, and during that time, it’s become even more clear how poorly served we are by our “elected representatives,” on both sides of the aisle. Yes, whether you are red or blue, there’s blood below for you.
On the right, in the past few days we’ve seen a Facebook poll asking “Should Obama die,” followed by a Republican representative declaring that Obama is “an enemy of humanity,” followed by a columnist at NewsMax declaring the only solution to the “Obama problem” is a military coup.
Where I come from, the United States of America, that’s called sedition (The Smith Act of 1940 makes it “a crime to advocate or teach the desirability of overthrowing the United States Government, or to be a member of any organization which does the same. It was often used against Communist organizations.”). Perhaps that’s why NewsMax pulled the column (closing the barn door after the horses are gone). Apparently our time honored tradition of democratic elections that has worked for over 220 years is just not good enough for some on the right.
I feel like I’m witnessing the Republican Party committing an ugly bloody suicide, perhaps seeing who they can take with them. I do know this; until I see some repentance for obvious sins, or at least acknowledgement the fringe has gone too far, this Independent Voter will not vote for a Republican for dogcatcher. The party seems to have not only completely lost its way, but has moved on to endangerment, of itself and others.
Or, in wonkese:
Politics is generally viewed as a zero-sum game: When one party gains, the other loses. But Republicans have pursued a strategy turning politics into a negative-sum game: Both parties lose. They have effectively harmed the Democrats’ agenda but done so at great cost to their own favorability numbers […] In 1994, Republicans managed to obstruct Clinton’s agenda in a way that effectively established them as an alternative. In 2009, they are battling Obama’s agenda in a manner that’s totally discrediting their party.
They even root against America, and cheer when she loses, because their hatred of Obama blinds all else. Apparently they love America during the four to eight years their party controls it, but when they are out of the Oval office, she can’t lose enough for their liking.
Even Joe Scarborough can’t help but see it:
Chicago is a beautiful city that would have made a perfect backdrop for the Olympics. The President was right to fly to Copenhagen to try to land the games, not for the sake of his city, but for the good of his country. The fact President Obama failed makes me respect him more for taking the chance, and the fact many right-wing figures opposed the President’s mission shows just how narrow-minded partisanship makes us all.
For the better part of 20 years, a bitterness has infected our politics that has weakened our country.
We Republicans spent eight years trying to delegitimize Bill Clinton.
Democrats spent the next eight years doing the same to George W. Bush.
Now that a Democrat is in the Oval Office again, it is the GOP who is trying to delegitimize a sitting president.
Some of the rhetoric is dangerous. But what we saw from some conservative corners regarding the President’s failed Olympics bid was just plain stupid.
Punishment at the voting booth is the only option. That is, for those who still believe in democracy. Those who think assassination, secession, or a military coup are solutions, I invite you to move to a country more suited to such attitudes. Perhaps Libya or Somalia. Maybe you could go knock off Castro and take over Cuba. Here, we vote, and accept the outcome, at least until the next election.
Not try and tear down the country for the next 4 years, like some giant hissy fit by a poor loser.
But on the left, We, The People weren’t really served any better this past week. In the Senate Finance Committee, the public option was shot down, not once, but twice. Both times, all Republicans voted against it, as expected, because that’s all The Party Of No has to offer on health care.
But it was truly defeated by Democrats. Five of them. Max Baucus (D-Mont), Kent Conrad (D-ND), Blanche Lincoln (D-Ark), Bill Nelson (D-Fla) and Tom Carper (D-Del). These five Democratic Senators represent states that contain, in total, less than 8% of the US population. Oh, and they apparently also represent the insurance companies that have collectively given them over $19 million dollars in “political donations.”
Furthermore, “The industry and interest groups have spent $380 million in recent months influencing healthcare legislation through lobbying, advertising and in direct political contributions to members of Congress. The largest contribution, totalling close to $1.5m, has gone to the chairman of the senate committee drafting the new law.”
Let’s call a spade a spade. These contributions are bribes. Perhaps not in a prosecutable sense. But just the same, they are huge multi-million dollar bribes of multiple public officials. And they worked.
We, The People, no longer control anything that happens in DC, left or right. We are so very screwed. I don’t have $19 million to bribe Senators, or a third of a billion to lobby/advertise in favor of a public option. Hell, I don’t even the $35,000 a year it would cost to buy health insurance for me and my wife.
Back in July I twittered, “I don’t want to lead you to believe the people debating our health care policy are self-interested idiots. I’d hate to ruin the surprise.”
It’s no surprise anymore.
On the left, I am at the mercy of the elected & bribed non-representatives, who band together in tiny numbers to gum up the whole works, perverting the idea of “majority rule.” In a country where 65% favor a public option, representatives of less than 8% of the population defeated it. And on the right, I am at the mercy of those who no longer seem to believe or participate in the democratic process, they are too busy rooting for America to lose. At anything, as long as it might make Obama look bad.
We are collectively covered in the bipartisan bullshit they’ve been slinging. And they’ve been slinging it so long, we don’t even notice the smell any more. They have to let loose with some truly noxious offal for us to even notice.
Which is exactly the way they want it. They are winning. We, The People, are losing.
Published 11:46AM, Sat, Oct 03 2009
Category: Politics
Previous: «« A Day For Accounting, 2009 ««
Next: »» The Not So Public Option »»
Peanut Gallery
I’ll have to pretty much ditto what Dan said. Great commentary. If I was naive, I’d say, “If P-dude gets it, and I get it, why don’t our politicians? They’re not stupid.” No, they’re just seeing which way the money flows.
Naive? Maybe I am a little at that. I’m feeling kind of “wee-wee’d up” watching the daily go-round, but sometimes I step back a little. We came about a hair’s breadth from Depression2. No one likes the bank bailouts and the bonuses when we the people are out here making choices between meat(!) and spaghetti again (and again). But money is flowing; orders are coming in, bills are getting paid. It could’ve been a whole lot worse.
If the health care shenanigans end up with something like the Prescription Drugs giveaway bill that went through a few years ago, no one will be more upset than me. But as Marlon Brando said in One-Eyed Jacks, “Ain’t hung yet.” It ain’t over yet, either.
I tried to do the right thing by writing to our Washington leaders. I had hoped that I would at least get something I could prove they were listening. I never got any response from Isakson; other than to say he was very busy in his canned letter. Chambliss did reply when the “response requested” was clicked – then after about 3 of these I realized they were also canned letters. Chambliss has just found a writer who is better at “sugar coated B.S.” than Isakson.
I had many tell me neither would do a thing, that they were cold hearted bastards and well by golly I’m now convinced. No further debate on that issue. Amazing how the Republican Party has managed to take a southern girl, spoon fed via the republican party scripture and completely convert her to the other side. My dad is rolling over in his grave – or applauding me from heaven.
“I had many tell me neither would do a thing, that they were cold hearted bastards”
I cannot imagine who would tell you such a thing.
It would seem I have the exact same set of elected representatives (funny, that), and I know that one of them, John Lewis, does not need my letter because he’s in favor of health reform. The other two, Isakson & Chambliss, do not need my letter because, well, they are cold-hearted bastards who are members of The Party Of No who will never ever lift a finger to support health reform. No matter how many letters they get from their “constituents,” i.e., the people they are supposed to represent.
The truth is they represent the Republican Party, first, and second place goes to those vested interests that donate to their coffers. We, The People, are a distant third.
Thus, I heartily endorse the proposal of Nicholas Kristoff, “that if health reform fails this year, 15 percent of members of Congress, along with their families, randomly lose all health insurance and another 8 percent receive inadequate coverage.”
They have no skin in the game, never have, protected by their gold plated government insurance (the kind they say will destroy the universe, if the rest of us get it). It’s time they did.
Or, alternately, they could give us a shot at what they’ve got … a government administered plan.
But as you well know, I’m a total cynic on this issue. Nothing good will come out of this, not for We, The People.



Oh, for the days when you were writing like this at least once a week!
I understand why you aren’t doing it that way now, but I’ve always looked forward to your insight and comments. I stop by once a week for that reason even now.
Keep up the fine writing!