Tue. Jul 17, 2007
Michael Vick, Knee Deep In the Dog's Business
The dark cloud that’s been hanging over Michael Vick and the Atlanta Falcons for three months finally issued a downpour. After county officials in Virginia effectively let the clock run out on their “investigation,” the feds took over a few weeks ago, and now a grand jury has charged Vick with a felony.
While I’ve been a fan of the Falcons for thirty years, I’ve been a “fan” of animals of all kinds a lot longer than that. They are God’s creations as much as you or I. And though one should presume innocence, aware that a grand jury is shown only one side of the story, the indictment released in this case is maddening, disgusting … and convincing.
A federal grand jury on Tuesday indicted Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick for his alleged role in a well-established dogfighting operation in Virginia where breeders fought pit bulls for purses as high as $26,000 and some losing dogs were electrocuted, drowned, hanged or shot to death.
In at least two instances, in 2003 — no dates were specified but Vick sat out much of that season with a foot injury — Vick traveled from Atlanta to South Carolina to participate in dogfights, according to the indictment.
The dogs that fared poorly, as well as those that didn’t perform well in test fights, met a cruel fate, the grand jury concluded.
“In or about April 2007,” the indictment said, “Peace, Phillips and Vick executed approximately 8 dogs that did not perform well … by various methods, including hanging, drowning, and slamming at least one dog’s body to the ground.”
The men are all charged with conspiracy to travel in interstate commerce in aid of unlawful activities and to sponsor a dog in an animal fighting venture.
If convicted on the travel portion of the charge, each man faces up to five years in federal prison. If convicted on the animal fighting portion, each is looking at a year behind bars.
AJC: Indictment details extensive dogfighting operation
You can read the indictment as a PDF for yourself. You’ll find sentences like, “In or about March of 2003, Peace, after consulting with Vick about the losing female pit bull’s condition, executed the losing dog by wetting the dog down with water and electrocuting the animal..”
Along the way you’ll read about Vick traveling from Virginia to North Carolina to place a dog in a fight. You’ll read about him traveling from Atlanta to South Carolina for another fight … during the fall of 2003 when he was out with a leg injury. You’ll read about him personally collecting or paying off tens of thousands of dollars because the dog he sponsored won or lost the fight. And, as above, you’ll read about what happened to the losers.
Reading the sordid details, you’ll see the feds have not one, not two, but four cooperating witnesses. This is not just one disgruntled guy making a plea deal. Four witnesses to so many multiple incidents that the indictment runs 18 pages long.
Michael Vick has claimed his relatives lived there and he knew nothing about it. But it’s instructive to know he bought this property within a couple of months of being drafted in 2001. In other words, it’s one of the first things he bought once he had enough money to buy anything he wanted. And the indictment alleges his personal involvement extended to April of this year.
And that’s the “known knowns” at this time. Anything else is speculation.
So let’s get started.
Sometime within four days on either side of the start of the Falcons training camp on July 26th (potentially even that same day), Michael Vick will appear in a federal court in Virginia. He won’t officially be arrested, but he’ll be fingerprinted and get a mug shot, plus maybe have to post bond. And during the critical first week of training camp under a new coaching staff, every player will be asked by a dozen reporters how they feel about Michael Vick’s case. And Michael will be busy coming up with new ways to dodge the media flock.
Then the best lawyers a $130 million salary can buy will begin their legal maneuvering. The case will be nowhere near resolved before the season begins in September, and therefore I’d bet his lawyers will make sure it gets continued into 2008. So … it will hang over this team for all 16 games. It will be a point of mockery on eight road trips, with signs and banners saying things about Vick I can’t even yet imagine.
And, oh, yeah, it will be a point of mockery at home games, as well. You think the fans have forgotten the finger Vick raised at them last year?
And somewhere during the course of those 16 games, Vick will break. Under the pressure, he will crack. At a time when his only possible redemption outside of a courtroom would be to put in that stellar season where he finally reaches his long heralded potential … the opposite will happen. Why am I so sure of that? Because it’s about character.
And if only a fraction of what the indictment alleges is true, Vick is not the kind of “stand up” guy who could pull that off. You see, back in April of this year, Vick was already in hot water because of [1] the water bottle incident and [2] blowing off an appointment with Congress. But he’d said he was going to change his ways, and buckle down for the coming season. So, what else was he doing in April? The indictment alleges “In or about April 2007, Peace, Phillips and Vick executed approximately 8 dogs that did not perform well … by various methods, including hanging, drowning, and slamming at least one dog’s body to the ground.”
If only a fraction of what the indictment alleges is true, Vick deserves everything he is about to get. And more.
Of course, my speculation about the coming season assumes that NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell allows Vick to play at all. For now, the NFL says…
“We are disappointed that Michael Vick has put himself in a position where a federal grand jury has returned an indictment against him,” NFL spokesman Brian McCarthy said.
“The activities alleged are cruel, degrading and illegal. Michael Vick’s guilt has not yet been proven, and we believe that all concerned should allow the legal process to determine the facts.”
ESPN: Federal grand jury indicts Vick in dogfighting case
However, Commissioner Goodell may lower the boom, as he recently has on others who have not yet been convicted: “Adam ‘Pacman’ Jones of Tennessee was suspended Tuesday for the 2007 NFL season and Chris Henry of Cincinnati received an eight-game suspension — both for numerous violations of the NFL’s personal conduct policy.”
Has Vick now entered that elite group? We’ll see. Commissioner Goodell doesn’t have to operate under the same presumption of innocence the courts do. He can punish a player just for tarnishing the NFL logo. He can decide to send a message, if the rumors are true that dog fighting is a part of the NFL culture for some players. But for no substantive reason whatsoever, I think he’ll hold off on any punishment during this coming season.
However, he’s just the “End Game Boss.” There are a couple of lower level Bosses who can shut Vick down just as hard. If I were new coach Bobby Petrino, who is not just concerned with this one coming season, but building a foundation for his system that will hopefully keep him employed for a long time … my depth chart just changed. Come the 26th when camp opens, D.J. Shockley gets the most practice time, followed by Joey Harrington. And I watch the waiver wires for an answered prayer while trying not to kick myself over the Matt Schaub trade.
Vick? He’s going to have his mind on dodging the press more than dodging the defense. He’s now a one-season stop-gap player, not the franchise. You can’t build a franchise on someone who may be [1] suspended by the NFL at any time, or [2] in jail next year.
Then there’s Arthur Blank. There is simply no telling what he might do. He’s obviously highly invested in Vick, and I don’t just mean his wallet. But he’s been frustrated with Vick before now, and this may push him over the line. I think he’s a bit like Goodell, in that you will not tarnish his product like that, and get a chance to do it again.
Regardless, either one of those three will lower the boom, or Vick will crack from this Sword of Damocles hanging over his head all season long. The end result is that Vick will not complete the coming season.
And I believe that next year, he’ll be gone, one way or another.
I once sang his praises. But if only a fraction of what the indictment alleges is true, in my opinion, he can’t be gone soon enough.
Later, 7/18/07: Poetic Justice Department, i.e., how this all started: “Authorities came to Vick’s compound April 25 after arresting his cousin, Davon Boddie, who lived there, on drug charges. Police said they made their case against Boddie a week before, in Hampton, Va., where a police dog named Troy sniffed marijuana in the trunk of a car.”
Published 10:44PM, Tue, Jul 17 2007
Category: Local Sports Atlanta
Previous: «« Seven ««
Next: »» Things That Used To Be American »»
Peanut Gallery
I agree emccee fleshy, Vick has to go!!!! Atlanta deserves better then this pea brain. Some good news however, Culpepper has been released from Miami. Kind of funny Harrington is already in ATL. But, the Falcons have to suck it up once again. Get rid of this idiot. Quickly.
I am so digusted to think that someone in Mr. Vick’s position would engage in this sort of activity. With the kind of education he recieved, and the money he has made, couldn’t he find something more productive to do with his time? Try doing something that young children can look up to, instead of stereotyping your race. Isn’t there enough prejudice towards African Americans, without someone in Mr. Vick’s position making those who already think that this is normal behaviour for African Americans, to behave this way? I live in the South, and believe me, there are a lot of people here who would say, “Oh well, what would you expect”. The African American community should be outraged at his actions. Even though innocent until proven guilty, if you own property, it is your responsibility to know what goes on there. Especially someone who is in the limelight and knows what could happen to his reputation. Apparently, Mr. Vick has not been concerned with his reputation in the past as well, from what I have read. What a shame for all of those children, especially the young men, to witness this lack of jugdement and character in someone they admire for their talents on the field. I only hope that the parents of these children will sit down and have and talk with their kids and tell them that Mr. Vick is a good example of a BAD example, and has behaved irresponsibly in whatever regard they find him guilty.
I believe in innocent until proven guilty, as everyone should. But the presidence has been set by the NFL Commisioner about player conduct and bringing discredit upon the NFL. Mike Vick has definately brought discredit upon the Atlanta Falcons and the NFL with, at the least, his poor judgement. Pacman Jones has been chastized for his friends so why not Vick. I am sure even if convicted Mchale Vick will pay a fine and move on and the others will get the prison sentence, that the way it works for people with money. It is a shame that real life is not an equal playing feild I would love to see him go to prison if he was involved and is convicted. I think it is time Atlanta cut their losses as well as the sponsors and the NFL, at least until this is over. I would never allow my kids to watch another game with him playing or buy anything he is sponsored by. Why should anyones time and money be devoted to some one so low and cruel.
If he is found guilty of these animal charges this man, I mean mental problem, should be put through exactly what he put those animals through.
What a vial and disgusting individual. You can’t even call that a human being.
With that being said his football career and image are a joke and he should just be put away and out of everyone else’s misery.
Our kids look up to high profile players like this. Are they going to go out and do things like this because it’s acceptable and he’s gotten away with it so why can’t they?
Geez!
It appears that when I wrote, “Sometime within four days on either side of the start of the Falcons training camp on July 26th (potentially even that same day), Michael Vick will appear in a federal court in Virginia,” I nailed it:
“While his Falcons teammates step onto the field for the first practice of training camp next week, quarterback Michael Vick will be in a court in Richmond, Va., facing federal charges for dog fighting. Vick is to appear at a 3:30 p.m. bond hearing before U.S. Magistrate Judge Dennis Dohnal and a 4 p.m. arraignment before U.S. District Judge Henry Hudson, who will handle the case that has put his career in jeopardy. The Falcons’ first practice begins at 3 p.m. the same day — a coincidence that promises to fuel the media maelstrom swirling around the team.”
Meanwhile, Arthur Blank had to return from taking his wife on a birthday trip to Africa in order to face this mess. I bet he’s in a fine mood.
Just because he has been accused, doesn’t mean he is guilty. The police informants that they have are probably some felons that are trying to get a lighter sentence. I think that Mike will get off because they have to prove without a reasonable doubt that he had involvement, and when it comes down to it, they will not be able to do that.
cutee4u: “I think that Mike will get off because they have to prove without a reasonable doubt that he had involvement, and when it comes down to it, they will not be able to do that.”
Maybe. Maybe not (emphasis mine):
Vick is in real trouble. He is up against the might and majesty of the U.S. government with all of its agents, all of its investigative techniques and all of its skilled prosecutors. If he has any doubts about the power and skill of the forces arrayed against him, he can call Scooter Libby, former chief of staff to Vice President Dick Cheney, or he can call Lord Conrad Black, the disgraced media mogul facing time in a federal penitentiary. If he still isn’t convinced, he can call Jeff Skilling, the zillionaire former Enron CEO who is residing in a federal pen. All three of them hired brilliant (and expensive) lawyers. All three thought they could explain their way out from under federal charges. And all three were convicted. Vick can, and probably will, hire some of America’s best defense lawyers, but they will face a serious battle.
The conspiracy charge will make things extra difficult for Vick and his lawyers. Under federal laws, the conspiracy charge allows federal prosecutors to link Vick to things that occurred even if he was not present. If the prosecutors can connect the four defendants, crimes committed by one of them can be used to add to the evidence against the others. It’s a tricky legal procedure that prosecutors love and defense lawyers detest.
It’s also worth noting again that there’s not one, but four cooperating witnesses. Since Vick’s cousin Boddie, the guy who lived at that address, is not among those charged, one might assume he’s turned on his cuz’.
I can’t believe this whole situation. Of course he must be proven guilty. It isn’t evryday that people accuse you of such things…. which leads me to believe he is affiliated.
I think if he is guilty we should water him down and electocute him or lets torture him, force him to fight like he has done to these poor animals. Eye for an eye tooth for tooth.
In the end he must face his maker and I don’t wish him luck.
I think if he is guilty we should water him down and electocute him or lets torture him, force him to fight like he has done to these poor animals. Eye for an eye tooth for tooth.
Whoa, folks! Let’s not sacrifice civilization itself. Having a $140,000,000 contract voided (not counting endorsements) and spending three to five in the pen is probably enough. Although, given the choice, some people in Vick’s position might choose your way.
Still, he’s innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law. That’s the standard for punishment by the government.
However, the standard for thinking somebody’s a jerk and not buying their products anymore is considerably lower. In my eyes, that lower standard has been mightily surpassed.
While the legal standard for conviction may be quite high, the standard for league action is much lower.
Pacman Jones got a years suspension without being convicted of a crime. The precedent is there and it would seem to me that an 18-page indictment alleging an ongoing criminal enterprise is a little more significant than a few drunken brawls outside strip joints.
Then again, we’re talking about a franchise player in a booming market. This kind of controversy is only good for TV ratings and in the end that is what the league cares about. As far as the Falcons go if they release him they will take a salary cap hit of somewhere around 16 million bucks over two years — that’s gotta hurt no matter how deep the teams pockets.
I wouldn’t expect Vick to go anywhere except prison — say, about, three years from now.
Can’t wait for the Falcons. I’ve decided that Mike Vick won’t start for my NFL team this year. I’m switching to my backup QB: Philip Rivers.
Go Chargers!
-
(As a longtime ATLien, I feel terrible about this. But I do have a reason: I live in San Diego now. That’s why, as untrustworthy opportunists go, I’ve still got more way more integrity than Mike Jacobs!)
No matter what happens in the court of law, you can not eradicate the mind of a socio-path. Even if he is ultimately locked in a cell to ponder all his sins, my guess is he’ll rationalize it all as he has done since 2001. People who are drawn to this type of “entertainment”, are sick, sadistic monsters born without a key brain component called “a conscience”. It is truly scary that pieces of human garbage exist in our society to such an extent. Michael Vick will get most of the media’s attention but the horrific and brutal behavior of probably thousands across the country in urban cities, will go merrily on. It is a culture of pure evil, floating through street sewers without a care in the world.



I believe strongly in the presumption of innocence. But even if Vick is ultimately found not-guilty, I still don’t see how anybody with any judgment at all could be anywhere near this sort of activity for any sustained period of time.
People in the public eye get caught doing bad things all of the time. Often, we forgive them, even if they’re guilty. That’s partially because a lot of us can see, with a couple of bad decisions and some bad luck, how we ourselves could get in similar situations.
But dogfighting? For seven years? Even if Vick’s involvement was as remote as possible – some bad-egg family members and friends living in his house in another state – I still can’t see a decent human being putting themselves anywhere near that situation for any amount of time.
It now looks like Vick is a really bad guy. But at the very least he’s got unbelievably bad judgment. That’s not a guy I want calling the signals in any huddle that I care about.
I have defended #7 for years. Those days are long gone.
This is Goodbye, Mike.